Dog training collars can make our dogs healthier and more prepared for any situation. Since we are willing to make our pups be trained and look after for themselves, we have to get a good dog gadget that can give a stimulus control for unwanted behavior. Garmin Alpha 200i and Dogtra 1900S are the trending waterproof e-collars with navigation. Let’s compare them and see which is better.
Pros And Cons Of Garmin VS Dogtra 1900S
Pros
- BPowered by inReach technology
- Uses TFT sunlight-readable touchscreen
- Compatible with TT15, TT15 mini, and T5, T5 mini.
- Uses barometric altimeter for navigation sensors which means better accuracy at monitoring ascent/descent, air pressure trends, etc.
- Durable and waterproof Can monitor up to 20 dogs at a time and updates every 2.5 seconds
- Design for dogs of 35 lb and up
- Can be adapted for dogs with a neck from 20 to 26 in.
- Range of 1320 yards
- Waterproof
- 127 training levels
- 3 Training modes
- Guaranty of no interferences with other electronic devices
- Customer service from the USA
- Fast battery charge
- For all dog stages
Cons
- Costly device
- Clunky app and sometimes difficult to navigate
- Requires subscription for the inReach tech
- Only 1 Dog tracking collar included
Garmin 200i
Pros
- BPowered by inReach technology
- Uses TFT sunlight-readable touchscreen
- Compatible with TT15, TT15 mini, and T5, T5 mini.
- Uses barometric altimeter for navigation sensors which means better accuracy at monitoring ascent/descent, air pressure trends, etc.
- Durable and waterproof Can monitor up to 20 dogs at a time and updates every 2.5 seconds
Cons
- Costly device
- Clunky app and sometimes difficult to navigate
- Requires subscription for the inReach tech
Dogtra 1900S
Pros
- Design for dogs of 35 lb and up
- Can be adapted for dogs with a neck from 20 to 26 in.
- Range of 1320 yards
- Waterproof
- 127 training levels
- 3 Training modes
- Guaranty of no interferences with other electronic devices
- Customer service from the USA
- Fast battery charge
- For all dog stages
Cons
- Only 1 Dog tracking collar included
General Features Of Garmin VS Dogtra 1900S
Training Features
The training features of Garmin Alpha 200i includes:
- Momentary Stimulation - only produces a very short stimulation when pressing the training key.
- Continuous Simulation - gives stimulation to your dog as long as you are pressing the training key (max. 8 seconds).
- Vibration - same with the continuous simulation above, the vibration lasts as long as you are pressing the training key (also max. 8 seconds).
- Tone - same with continuous simulation and vibration, the device emits tone the entire period you are pressing the training key.
Dogtra, can be used in bigger dogs. This is why it's recommended to use other dog collars if you're not dedicated to that, but if you are, for better results it would be better buying Dogtra.
Garmin 200i
The training features of Garmin Alpha 200i includes:
- Momentary Stimulation - only produces a very short stimulation when pressing the training key.
- Continuous Simulation - gives stimulation to your dog as long as you are pressing the training key (max. 8 seconds).
- Vibration - same with the continuous simulation above, the vibration lasts as long as you are pressing the training key (also max. 8 seconds).
- Tone - same with continuous simulation and vibration, the device emits tone the entire period you are pressing the training key.
Dogtra 1900S
Dogtra, can be used in bigger dogs. This is why it's recommended to use other dog collars if you're not dedicated to that, but if you are, for better results it would be better buying Dogtra.
Range
The Garmin Alpha 200i can reach a range up to 4 miles when used with TT15 mini and TT5 mini while it can reach up to a range of 9 miles when used with TT15 or TT5.
Dogtra has a bigger range which gives you better control over the dog you are training with a range of 1320, both count with a DryTek technology that makes them waterproof.
Garmin 200i
The Garmin Alpha 200i can reach a range up to 4 miles when used with TT15 mini and TT5 mini while it can reach up to a range of 9 miles when used with TT15 or TT5.
Dogtra 1900S
Dogtra has a bigger range which gives you better control over the dog you are training with a range of 1320, both count with a DryTek technology that makes them waterproof.
Stimulation Levels
The Garmin Alpha 200i has two training options for stimulation: the linear stimulation and the traditional. The default intensity option is linear which has 1 to 18 levels of progressive stimulation, but you can always change this to traditional stimulation which lets you adjust the stimulation settings from low to medium to high or vice versa. The traditional option has six predetermined levels of stimulation.
Dogtra offers you 127 graining levels, so you can adjust it to any dog, and also offers you 3 training modes, so you can adapt the device to your needs, depending on the dog's reaction and response to the stimulus.
Garmin 200i
The Garmin Alpha 200i has two training options for stimulation: the linear stimulation and the traditional. The default intensity option is linear which has 1 to 18 levels of progressive stimulation, but you can always change this to traditional stimulation which lets you adjust the stimulation settings from low to medium to high or vice versa. The traditional option has six predetermined levels of stimulation.
Dogtra 1900S
Dogtra offers you 127 graining levels, so you can adjust it to any dog, and also offers you 3 training modes, so you can adapt the device to your needs, depending on the dog's reaction and response to the stimulus.
Design
Garmin Alpha 200i has a rugged design that looks just like a small handheld two-way radio. It weighs 280 grams and has dimensions of 6.8 x 16.2 x 3.4 cm (not including the antenna). This device sports a sunlight-readable TFT transflective touchscreen with 282 x 470 pixels resolution and display size of 4.7 x 7.7 cm (W x H) and 3.5 inch or 88.9 mm diag.
The design for Dogtra is better talking about making the dog feel comfortable with the collar due to its ergonomic design.
Garmin 200i
Garmin Alpha 200i has a rugged design that looks just like a small handheld two-way radio. It weighs 280 grams and has dimensions of 6.8 x 16.2 x 3.4 cm (not including the antenna). This device sports a sunlight-readable TFT transflective touchscreen with 282 x 470 pixels resolution and display size of 4.7 x 7.7 cm (W x H) and 3.5 inch or 88.9 mm diag.
Dogtra 1900S
The design for Dogtra is better talking about making the dog feel comfortable with the collar due to its ergonomic design.
Conclusion
In this comparison, Garmin is the winner. It has better navigation features, more stimulation modes, and has a more readable display. Those factors are what make Garmin meet your dog training needs. It even lets you monitor up to 20 dogs and can serve as a GPS collar. Worth the cost indeed.
IMPORTANT NOTE: If you found this comparison helpful and decided on buying Garmin 200i, I would highly appreciate if you use my referral link for purchasing. I will receive a small commission at no cost to you. It will keep me motivated to buy expensive dog gadgets, properly test them and provide unbiased reviews.
-
Mark is a Boston University graduate and former electrical engineer. In 2017, he decided to combine his tech knowledge with his love for dogs. He spent a year familiarizing himself with the latest GPS tracking collars, invisible fences, and other hot pet gadgets before he wrote his first product review. After selling Technobark, Mark remained a writer and consultant but spends more time on his other passion now: raising and training his growing family of dogs.
View all posts
If you click this link and make a purchase, we earn a commission at no additional cost to you. 2024-04-20
Leave a Comment