Sportdog vs Dogtra: Which Dog Training Collar is Better?

SportDOG training collar vs. Dogtra
Written by Mark Braeden

Sportdog and Dogtra are products that are both training collars specially designed for training dogs. We have written this Sportdog VS Dogtra article to compare them side-by-side to show their differences and uniqueness, for you to be able to decide which one to finally buy in the end.

Before starting with the description of the product I would only like to say that these collars were created with the purpose of training dogs, these devices should never be used for torturing a dog, and they must be used wisely.

Both products have practically the same usage, just at a different level. While a collar has a bigger range the other has better adaptability to the dogs you’re trying to train, but let’s see this in a chart, so, you can easily see the main differences.

SportDOG 425X
SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers - 500 Yard Range...
Dogtra 1900S
Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar - 3/4 Mile Range,...
Pros
  • 3 Dog tracking
  • Design for dogs of 8 lb and up
  • Can be adapted for dogs with a neck from 5 to 22 in.
  • Waterproof
  • Option for a buzzing or whistle
  • Counts with local customer service
  • 1 Year of guarantee
  • Fast battery charge
  • For all dog stages
  • Cheaper than Dogtra
  • Design for dogs of 35 lb and up
  • Can be adapted for dogs with a neck from 20 to 26 in.
  • Range of 1320 yards
  • Waterproof
  • 127 training levels
  • 3 Training modes
  • Guaranty of no interferences with other electronic devices
  • Customer service from the USA
  • Fast battery charge
  • For all dog stages
Cons
  • Range of 500 yeards compare to 1320 yards with Dogtra
  • Just 1 collar in the package, for training three dogs it's necessary to buy separately the other 2 collars
  • Only 1 Dog tracking collar included
  • More expensive than Dogtra
More Information
SportDOG 425X
SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers - 500 Yard Range...
Pros
  • 3 Dog tracking
  • Design for dogs of 8 lb and up
  • Can be adapted for dogs with a neck from 5 to 22 in.
  • Waterproof
  • Option for a buzzing or whistle
  • Counts with local customer service
  • 1 Year of guarantee
  • Fast battery charge
  • For all dog stages
  • Cheaper than Dogtra
Cons
  • Range of 500 yeards compare to 1320 yards with Dogtra
  • Just 1 collar in the package, for training three dogs it's necessary to buy separately the other 2 collars
More Information
Dogtra 1900S
Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar - 3/4 Mile Range,...
Pros
  • Design for dogs of 35 lb and up
  • Can be adapted for dogs with a neck from 20 to 26 in.
  • Range of 1320 yards
  • Waterproof
  • 127 training levels
  • 3 Training modes
  • Guaranty of no interferences with other electronic devices
  • Customer service from the USA
  • Fast battery charge
  • For all dog stages
Cons
  • Only 1 Dog tracking collar included
  • More expensive than Dogtra
More Information

Training Features

SportDOG 425 transmitter vs. Dogtra

SportDOG 425X
SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers - 500 Yard Range...
Dogtra 1900S
Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar - 3/4 Mile Range,...
SportDog counts with a system able to train three dogs at the same time, also the collar can be adapted for smaller dogs which are good for people working with training dogs or for aficionados, but Dogtra has a more complex system and can be better adapted to any dog due to the number of training levels and the training modes it has.
Dogtra, different from SportDog just can be used in bigger dogs than SportDog, this is why it's recommended to use Sportdog if you're not dedicated to that, but if you are, for better results it would be better buying Dogtra.
SportDOG 425X
SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers - 500 Yard Range...
SportDog counts with a system able to train three dogs at the same time, also the collar can be adapted for smaller dogs which are good for people working with training dogs or for aficionados, but Dogtra has a more complex system and can be better adapted to any dog due to the number of training levels and the training modes it has.
Dogtra 1900S
Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar - 3/4 Mile Range,...
Dogtra, different from SportDog just can be used in bigger dogs than SportDog, this is why it's recommended to use Sportdog if you're not dedicated to that, but if you are, for better results it would be better buying Dogtra.

Range

SportDOG 425X
SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers - 500 Yard Range...
Dogtra 1900S
Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar - 3/4 Mile Range,...
Although SportDog can train 3 dogs at the same time, it has a shorter range area counting with a range of 500 yds. SportDog can keep controlling the dog even in the middle or under the water, its technology helps to keep control even 24. 9 under the water.
Dogtra has a bigger range which gives you better control over the dog you are training with a range of 1320, both count with a DryTek technology that makes them waterproof.
SportDOG 425X
SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers - 500 Yard Range...
Although SportDog can train 3 dogs at the same time, it has a shorter range area counting with a range of 500 yds. SportDog can keep controlling the dog even in the middle or under the water, its technology helps to keep control even 24. 9 under the water.
Dogtra 1900S
Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar - 3/4 Mile Range,...
Dogtra has a bigger range which gives you better control over the dog you are training with a range of 1320, both count with a DryTek technology that makes them waterproof.

Stimulation Levels

SportDOG 425X
SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers - 500 Yard Range...
Dogtra 1900S
Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar - 3/4 Mile Range,...
SportDog offers you 21 training levels, so you can adjust them to the dog in any dog stage, and it also counts with some training modes that could help you to have better control.
Dogtra offers you 127 graining levels, so you can adjust it to any dog, and also offers you 3 training modes, so you can adapt the device to your needs, depending on the dog's reaction and response to the stimulus.
SportDOG 425X
SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers - 500 Yard Range...
SportDog offers you 21 training levels, so you can adjust them to the dog in any dog stage, and it also counts with some training modes that could help you to have better control.
Dogtra 1900S
Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar - 3/4 Mile Range,...
Dogtra offers you 127 graining levels, so you can adjust it to any dog, and also offers you 3 training modes, so you can adapt the device to your needs, depending on the dog's reaction and response to the stimulus.

Design

SportDOG collar design vs. Dogtra collae

SportDOG 425X
SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers - 500 Yard Range...
Dogtra 1900S
Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar - 3/4 Mile Range,...
SportDog has a different design and is less comfortable for the dog, it counts with a better adaptation to the size of the dog, letting small dogs use the collar without any problem.
The design for Dogtra is better talking about making the dog feel comfortable with the collar due to its ergonomic design.
SportDOG 425X
SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers - 500 Yard Range...
SportDog has a different design and is less comfortable for the dog, it counts with a better adaptation to the size of the dog, letting small dogs use the collar without any problem.
Dogtra 1900S
Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar - 3/4 Mile Range,...
The design for Dogtra is better talking about making the dog feel comfortable with the collar due to its ergonomic design.

Battery life and charging time

Both devices have the same charging time of two hours, also both devices have a battery charge indicator, so you can see the life of the battery, SportDog has lithium batteries for a shorter time of charge.

Our verdict

Both products are good for dog training (same as Garmin collars), they have good quality and useful features, nevertheless, I couldn’t exactly say one is better than the other because they have different ways they can be used and be better than the other.

For example, let’s talk about SportDog, this collar can track 3 dogs at the same time, and it does not have the same training levels as Dogtra, or the same range, but it can easily adapt to a bigger variety of dogs with different stages, which tells me this device is perfect for amateur or semi-professional dog trainers who just want to train the dog so, it improves his domestic behavior, also for normal people who want to train his dog at home. But if you want to train a dog more professionally, maybe Dogtra is a better option. Dogtra, unlike SportDog, just can track one dog, but it has a better range and offers you better control over the dog you want to train. Dogtra has a better and more comfortable design for the dog but it just can be used in bigger dogs, different from SportDog. This may be to focus on the kind of dogs that are trained professionally for special tasks, and not in the house, also SportDog has a much smaller price than Dogtra, making it more accessible to anyone who wants to train his dog, and Dogtra has a more expensive price, but offers better control over the dog.

So, as a conclusion, the best product talking about features is Dogtra due to it has better specifications talking about dog and stimulus control, but you may not like to spend 300 dollars for a collar that you will use once with your dog until he learns where to make pee, so the best product will be the one adjusted to your needs. If you’re on your way to be a professional trainer, I would recommend you try Dogtra, but if you just want to train your dog at home, it would be better to buy SportDog.

Technbark's Winner
Dogtra 1900S
Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar - 3/4 Mile Range,...
414 Reviews
Technbark's Winner
Dogtra 1900S
Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar - 3/4 Mile Range,...
414 Reviews

If you click this link and make a purchase, we earn a commission at no additional cost to you.  2020-12-02

About the author

Mark Braeden

Mark is the dog breeder for 17 years. Mark also has 4 dogs: Alaskan Malamute, Clumber Spaniel, Irish Terrier and Mutt. Mark also into latest technologies and he is trying all the latest dog gadgets on the market and sharing his experience.

Leave a Comment